Tuesday, April 1, 2014

Sacred Laziness and the Gift of Wisdom (1 Kings 19:2-16; Lent 4 (series); March 30, 2014)



Sacred Laziness and the Gift of Wisdom

1 Kings 19:2-16
Lent 4 (series)
March 30, 2014

Rev. John M. Caldwell, PhD
First United Methodist Church
Decorah, IA

We're struggling in our culture, in our country, in our world, with wisdom.  Oh, we have enormous amounts of knowledge and more of it all the time.  Buckminster Fuller observed that the world's knowledge doubled every century until 1900 and then every twenty-five years by the end of WW II.  Now, it is said that the world's knowledge is doubling every thirteen months.[1]

I don't know if I accept that.  It is certainly true that every time I snap a picture with my phone there are two million more bytes of data in the world.  Judging by the number of pictures posted on Facebook, there are a lot of us snapping picture with cell phones.  That adds up to a lot of data being produced.  But I hesitate to call one more "selfie" more information, let alone more knowledge.  And it certainly isn't wisdom.

We usually say that wisdom is the result of much experience.  Older people, we say, are wise because of their long years and many experiences.  But wisdom is more than that.  Wisdom is the result of experience and reflection on that experience.  Reflection is what happens when we give our experiences enough time and enough attention so that they can teach us what they have to teach.  Wisdom doesn't come automatically with years and there are, sad to say, plenty of foolish older people who have gained little from their years because they have never given their lives time to speak to them. 

A tragedy of our era is how little we respect the older members of our families and communities.  If we respected them more, they might grow and become our elders.  They might even do the hard work needed to become wise. 

But we don't really value wisdom.  We've stopped looking to our elders for wisdom and many of them have stopped pursuing it.  They're "spending their children's inheritance," as the bumper sticker says.  They're spending their last years shuttling back and forth between their winter and summer homes, playing golf, and complaining to anyone who will listen about the generations coming behind them.  There are a number of reasons for this, I suppose.  Among them would be the pace of technological change.  While older people are trying to wrap their heads around email, young people have moved on to text messaging, Twitter, and social media.  Ten years ago or so, my sister Jody, a librarian at Drew University and the head of bibliographic instruction, started giving first year students a tour of the library stacks to show them where the books are kept.  There are some things that cannot be found on line.  Some information, some knowledge, is to be found in the pages of an actual book that you can hold in your hand, an actual book with pages that you turn, a book that has that slightly musty smell that permeates all academic libraries.

We don't really value wisdom.  With wisdom neglected and with older adults so far behind the knowledge curve it is little wonder that so many of them have decided to spend the balance of their lives in the pursuit of frivolous irrelevance. 

Our culture and our world are facing a deep crisis that we will either meet in the next twenty or thirty years or the earth itself will be so changed that humanity will face oppressive and widespread misery.   Our attitude toward wisdom needs to change.  We have plenty of data, information and knowledge, enough to tell us the nature of the interlocking crises that are bearing down on us.  But none of those things will tell us how to meet the challenge.  None of these things will call forth the courage needed to make the decisions we need to make.  And none of these things will give us the resolve to move forward and keep moving forward in the absence of absolute certainty.

For these things we need wisdom and it's in short supply.  I went to Ask.com and asked, "How can we save humankind?"  The first response was to ask if I meant, "How can we save mankind?"  No, that's not what I meant.  I meant womankind, too.  So I already know that I'll have to make my way through a certain amount of sexism.  What else is new? 

Okay, so, "How do we save mankind?"  What pops up first are a series of ads.  "Mankind: The Story of All of Us" at history.com.  History might be helpful, so all right.  Then comes "How We Can Save" at wow.com.  After that comes "Can Saves" at target.com.  Then there is a link to nature.org that connects us to information about water supplies.  Better, maybe.  Then a link to a directory of small businesses provided by Dun and Bradstreet.  I like small business, but I'm not sure there is an answer to my question in that directory. 

Next come several references to a book entitled, Only You Can Save Mankind."  This sounds promising but it turns out that Only You Can Save Mankind is a science fiction novel by Terry Pratchett.  Knowing Pratchett's work, it's sure to be funny and entertaining, but it's not what I was looking for.

You cannot Ask.com for wisdom.  You cannot Google it.  Wisdom might be found somewhere on the interwebs, but there is no algorithm that would recognize wisdom if it popped up.  It takes a wise person to recognize wisdom.  We're in trouble.

We'll have to become wise the hard way, by being open to our own and each other's experiences and by spending the empty time we need to let that process work.  "Sabbath," says Wayne Muller, "is an incubator for wisdom."[2]  Sabbath--rest, cessation of work--is what is needed.  But Sabbath as we know is in short supply.  We keep ourselves very busy.  We are doing good things, of course.  By themselves each of the things we do is important and justifiable.  But together they guarantee that we will never have the time for reflection.  They guarantee that we will never become wise.  Muller said it this way twenty-five years ago and, if anything, what he observes is even truer now than it was then:

Our culture invariably supposes that action and accomplishment are better than rest, that doing something—anything—is better than doing nothing. Because of our desire to succeed, to meet these ever-growing expectations, we do not rest. Because we do not rest, we lose our way. We miss the compass points that would show us where to go, we bypass the nourishment that would give us succor. We miss the quiet that would give us wisdom. We miss the joy and love born of effortless delight. Poisoned by this hypnotic belief that good things come only through unceasing determination and tireless effort, we can never truly rest. And for want of rest, our lives are in danger.[3]

We're not the only ones living out the truth that Muller has uncovered.  The prophet in our today's reading, Elijah the Tishbite, lived it too.  He was someone I think we could have admired had he lived among us.  Admired and disliked.  He had a tendency to meddle in politics.  He assumed that God's passionate commitment to justice required him to do that.  Our reading this morning comes at the end of what was arguably the most dramatic episode of his ministry. 

In Elijah's day, the covenant people were politically divided.  The kingdom of Judah in the South was ruled by members of David's dynasty.  The Kingdom of Israel in the North was ruled by a series of dynasties.  In Elijah's time King Ahab and Queen Jezebel were sponsoring and leading Israel in the worship of Canaanite gods, a divine couple named Ba'al and Asherah.  Ba'al and Asherah were fertility gods.  Ahab and Jezebel were leading Israel to turn its back on Yahweh their covenant God.  Yahweh sent Elijah north to overthrow the Ba'al and Asherah cult and call the people back to covenant faithfulness to Yahweh.  So Elijah went north.

He called out the prophets of Ba'al and Asherah and challenged them to a contest.  Israelites gathered to watch and see what would happen.  Elijah addressed them: "How long will you go limping with two different opinions? If the Lord is God, follow him; but if Baal, then follow him....I, even I only, am left a prophet of the Lord; but Baal's prophets number four hundred fifty."  The four hundred fifty of Ba'al's prophets would take a bull, butchering it and laying its pieces on wood laid on a stone altar.  Elijah would do the same.  Then the prophets of Ba'al would appeal to their god to send fire.  Elijah would call upon Yahweh.  Whichever God sent fire would be recognized as Israel's God.  This seemed like a good idea to the gathered people. 

The prophets of Ba'al went first.  They cut up the bull and laid it on the wood on a stone altar.  Then they called on Ba'al.  "Send fire!" they prayed.  They danced.  They even cut themselves so that they offered their own blood to Ba'al.  But there was no fire. 

Evening was coming and the prophets of Ba'al had been at it all day.  Then Elijah took twelve stones and built an altar to Yahweh.  He laid wood on the altar.  He laid the pieces of his cut-up bull on the wood.  Then he dug a trench around the altar and had water poured over the offering and the wood until the trench around the altar was full of water.  Then he prayed, "O Lord, God of Abraham, Isaac, and Israel, let it be known this day that you are God in Israel, that I am your servant, and that I have done all these things at your bidding.  Answer me, O Lord, answer me, so that this people may know that you, O Lord, are God, and that you have turned their hearts back."

Just like that fire fell upon the offering and burned it up together with wood on the altar.  The fire even evaporated all the water.  The people fell on their faces and cried, "The Lord indeed is God!"  Elijah had them seize the four hundred fifty prophets of Ba'al and Asherah, took them to a nearby gully, and killed them all, dumping their bodies into the gully.

Of course, when Ahab and Jezebel found out about what had happened, they were furious.  Jezebel threatened Elijah with death.  Elijah ran south toward Judah.  He ran right into Judah, through it, and out the other side, still running.  He finally collapsed under a tree and prayed to die.

Instead, he fell asleep.  The next thing he knew an angel was shaking him awake.  "Elijah, get up.  Have something to eat."  There was a flatcake baking on a stone and a jar of water.  Elijah ate the cake and drank the water.  And then he fell asleep again.  Again, the angel shook him awake.  "Elijah, have some more to eat and drink."  Elijah did that and continued on his way to Mount Horeb.

At Horeb Elijah spent the night in a cave where he was met by God who asked him what he was doing there.  Elijah replied that he had been working very hard because God's people in the north had forsaken God, thrown down God's altars, killed all of God's prophets of whom Elijah was the last, and they were trying to kill him.  God told Elijah to stand out by entrance of the cave because God would pass by.  There was a great wind, an earthquake, and a fire, but God was not present in any of them.  Then there was "a sound of sheer silence" as the NSRV has it, "a sound.  Thin.  Quiet" in the CEB.  Elijah covered his face and left his cave to meet God.  "Elijah," said God, "why are you here?"  Elijah gave God the same answer as before, that he had been working very hard because God's people in the north had forsaken God, thrown down God's altars, killed all of God's prophets of whom Elijah was the last, and they were trying to kill him.

This is an odd thing.  Three times Elijah has said that he is the last of Yahweh's prophets.  But it isn't true.  Ahab's right hand man, Obadiah, had given shelter to one hundred of Yahweh's prophets, hiding them in two different caves and providing them with food and water.  And furthermore, Elijah knows this.  Obadiah told him this back in chapter eighteen. 

But Elijah is tired.  When we're tired we miss things.  Our view of the world becomes distorted.  We pay too much attention to some things and not enough to others.  Elijah missed what Obadiah told him.  And missing that important information, Elijah comes to a foolish conclusion about his world.  He comes to believe that God's justice is a hopeless cause.  He becomes despondent.  He comes to believe that the cause of God's justice is about him.  "I, have been very zealous...I alone am left, and they are seeking my life."  If anyone is in need of wisdom, it is one of God's prophets.

So what does God do for Elijah who has lost the way of wisdom?  The first thing that God does is to make sure that Elijah catches up on his sleep.  Then God feeds him.  God gives him some work: a couple of kings to anoint and a successor to name.  "Oh, and by the way," God says, "there are seven thousand Israelites who have remained faithful and who do not worship Ba'al and Asherah."   Rested, Elijah is ready to gain some wisdom, or perhaps to regain it.  God needed Elijah's wisdom in his time.

God needs our wisdom for our world.  We need Sabbath because it is "an incubator for wisdom."

My first preaching professor had a colleague who spent a good deal of time sitting on a dock by a river with a fishing pole in his hands, but he seldom caught anything.  For one thing, he didn't bother to bait his hook.  My professor asked him about it.  He said he wasn't actually fishing.  He was sitting and thinking.  Sometimes he worked on his sermon in his head.  Sometimes he just thought. 

Why the fishing pole, then?  His friend said, "Well, if I just sat here, my people would think I was lazy.  If it looks like I'm fishing, that's good enough for most of my folks."  This was a wise man or at least a man on his way to wisdom.

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA.





[1] David R. Schilling, “Knowledge Doubling Every 12 Months, Soon to be Every 12 Hours,” Industry Tap into News (2013).
[2] Wayne Muller, Sabbath: Finding Rest, Renewal, and Delight in Our Busy Lives (Bantam Books, 1999), 165.

[3] Ibid., 1.

We Are Not Cyborgs! (Genesis 1:26—2:3; Lent 3 (series); March 23, 2014)



We Are Not Cyborgs!

Genesis 1:26—2:3
Lent 3 (series)
March 23, 2014

Rev. John M. Caldwell, PhD
First United Methodist Church
Decorah, IA

Have you ever tried to convince a toddler to take a nap?  Toddlers need a lot of sleep and they need naps, but they don’t think so.  I guess they don’t want to miss out on whatever is going to be happening while they are asleep.  Whatever their reasons they resist taking a nap even when it’s obvious they need one.  They can be cranky and fussy.  Their eyes can be puffy.  Their cheeks can be bright red patches.  They can even be swaying on their feet.  But do they think they need a nap? 

I confess I don’t understand.  Imagine if someone came up to you, say, at two in the afternoon and said, “Gee, you look tired.  Why don’t you lie down for an hour or two?  Don’t worry about your work: someone else will do it, or it will wait, or it really doesn’t matter.”  Would you stomp your feet?  Would you say, “No!  I’m not tired!”?  Would you burst into tears?  Would you respond, as a little girl of our acquaintance did once, to the invitation to take a nap so that she would be rested and happy, “I’m happy now!”?  I don’t think so.  I sure wouldn’t.

We are short of sleep.  It’s not a new problem.  Something happened to time at about the same time that the factory system was developed.  Before that, our lives were shaped by the rhythms of night and day, summer and winter, the waxing and waning of the moon, the ebb and flow of the tides.  Our lives as human beings were lived according to human rhythms of life.

Factories changed that.  Factories—and they were textile mills at first—housed large numbers of looms, machines that ran by themselves.  The workers were needed to change spools of thread and to tend to needed repairs.  Humans had to adjust themselves to the operation of machines.  No production meant no profits for the mill owners.  One the biggest challenges faced by early factory owners and managers was getting workers to work with machine-like rhythm and without stopping for rest.  Machines do not need rest.  Idle machines meant no production. 

The biggest hurdle came when artificial light made it possible to operate factories around the clock.  Workers had to become even more machine-like by denying their bodies’ demand for sleep during the night and tend the machines instead.

Our system would like to figure out how we could go without sleep altogether since, except for mattresses and linens, when we are asleep we neither produce nor consume anything.  Any activity that involves neither production nor consumption is, in our system, by definition, worthless, valueless, useless.  Over the last century Americans’ average amount of sleep has fallen from ten hours a night to six and a half.  There is no reason to believe that the pressure toward less and less sleep will stop.  In fact, along with other military forces around the world, the US military hopes to reduce the hours of sleep needed by soldiers while leaving their abilities unimpaired so that soldiers may fight without fatigue for forty, sixty or even ninety hours.[1]  What might be justified in the life-or-death of combat is finding its way back into “ordinary” life.  Drugs—amphetamines or modanifil—are being used by college and even high school students to increase concentration during studying or high-stakes test-taking.

Our beastly system is finding ways to cure us of the so-called faults—like needing sleep—that come along with being human.  Our sleep deprivation is not the gift of more useable time; it is the beast’s theft from us of our birthright.[2]  It robs us the ability to become fully human.  It turns us into cyborgs: a half-human and half-machine state in which it is impossible to tell whether we are the organic extension of our tools or they are the technological extensions of us, a state in which we gain a world of super-powers at the cost of our true life. 

Our enforced sleeplessness is not new.  Reducing human beings made in the image of God to mere beasts or machines is an old story.  It is a feature of our treasury of shared stories and memories that form our scriptures.  In fact this story of oppressive over-work and under-rest is a central theme in the single story that lies at the heart of ancient Israel’s memory.  This story is so important that it provides the lens through which Israel sees itself, its experiences, and its world.

It is a story of unending work.  Israel had become a cog in the Egyptian imperial machine.  Pharaoh had set Israel to making mud bricks to build the warehouses needed to store the wealth of his empire.  As the account in Exodus puts it, “The Egyptians became ruthless in imposing tasks on the Israelites, and made their lives bitter with hard service in mortar and brick and in every kind of field labor.”[3] 

The Israelites were miserable, but they had no recourse.  Pharaoh was their master and he served the gods of Egypt.  The oppression of the Israelites was not an accident.  It was part of the imperial system.  There was no one they knew to whom they could appeal, so their cry was not to God; it was an incoherent cry to the universe at large.  But it did not go unheard.

Yahweh, the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob “heard their groaning…God looked upon the Israelites, and God took notice of them.”[4]  So God set in motion the rescue of Israel that we call the Exodus.  God recruited Moses to be a leader for the Israelites and a spokesperson in God’s dealings with Pharaoh.

Moses and his brother Aaron approached Pharaoh to demand that Pharaoh release the Israelites so that they could observe a festival and make sacrifices to God.  But this was something Pharaoh could not permit.  Pharaoh could recognize no claim higher than the claims of the empire and its gods.  Pharaoh responded by increasing Israel’s burden, commanding the taskmasters,

“You shall no longer give the people straw to make bricks, as before; let them go and gather straw for themselves.  But you shall require of them the same quantity of bricks as they have made previously; do not diminish it, for they are lazy; that is why they cry, ‘Let us go and offer sacrifice to our God.’  Let heavier work be laid on them; then they will labor at it and pay no attention to deceptive words.”[5]

Productivity, profit, and power are the values of empire.  Nothing must stand in the way of meeting brick quotas, certainly not the humanity of the workers who are making them.  If workers have time to complain, they can move faster.  This is life under the beast in its Egyptian form.

So it is no wonder that when God rescued Israel and provided a blueprint for how Israel would live in its new-found freedom from over-work, regular, community-wide rest was a key part of the plan.  It was even built in to the creation story.  In the first telling of the creation story, Yahweh creates the world in stupendous creative acts, spread over six days.  The last, the pinnacle, of the creation is human-kind, human-kind created in the image of God. 

And then God does a remarkable thing.  God does nothing for a whole day.  And in that wonderful phrase that is sprinkled through the stories of the saints: mirabile dictu, “marvelous to tell,” the universe does not fall apart.  It is such a good creation that it doesn’t need God’s constant attention.  It will go on without any intervention.  Even God can take a day off. 

And because God takes a day off, so can we.  If the universe does not need God’s constant attention, then it certainly does not need ours.  We can stop producing, stop consuming, and go off-line.  We can rest.  We can sleep.  There is room for all of that built into the structure of the universe itself. 

If we think we cannot rest.  If we think we cannot sleep.  If we think we cannot go off-line.  If we think we cannot stop being busy, for long enough to rest and recover, for long enough to be recharged and recreated, then we are lying to ourselves. 

But we didn’t invent the lie.  We were lied to.  We are being lied to. 

Sometimes those lies are pretty subtle, pretty sophisticated, pretty hard to detect.  But sometimes the lies are so brazen and so obvious I wonder how they think that can get away with it.  The Quaker Oats Company has an advertisement running.  A woman is asleep in a bus.  A woman and a man are both nodding off while sitting and waiting on hard chairs.  A six year old child falls asleep on his homework (Why does a six year old child have homework?  He should be outside playing with his dog who is also falling asleep on the floor beside the child’s chair!  Or better yet, why doesn’t he take a nap?).  A female voice-over declares, “Oh, there’s an energy crisis, all right: a human one.  And it’s time to fight it.”  In the meantime round cartons of Quaker Oatmeal are falling from the sky, like mannah, only with parachutes. 

Americans are sleep-deprived and tired.  The Quaker Oat Company’s answer is to encourage us to “Quaker Up” by buying and eating its products.  This is how our system responds to our lack of sleep; it urges us to buy and eat.  This is the work of the beast.

This is not the life we were meant for.  Yes, we were meant for a life of vigorous work for the common good.  We were meant for a life of learning about ourselves and each other and everything that the universe contains.  But we were also meant to take time to be with our families and friends, time to do something besides working, time to celebrate the mere fact that we are alive, and, yes, time for sleep.  A lot of sleep.  Eight hours or more.

Of course it is one thing to decide that we need more sleep.  And it is another thing entirely to get it.  We have people all around us who expect us to do this or that.  We have expectations of ourselves.  We have a powerful and invasive system that tells us that the more we do, the more we work, the more we buy, the better people we become.  There is always more to do than we can do in the time we have to do it.  We imagine that we can do more by sleeping less.  And we even have the Quaker Oatmeal Company telling us that we can substitute food for sleep.

What we could use, among other things, is a community that could help us to make a change, a group that could help us make a decision and deal with the pressures that come with making any  important changes, pressures that  come from other people and from the voices in our heads that try to guilt trip us.  This could be a Bubble Up ministry and the “group” could be as simple as a Facebook page that the members could check in with periodically.  If you’re interested in pursuing that, let me know.

In the meantime, let’s get some sleep, take a nap, eat lunch somewhere besides our desks, and take a deep breath every once in a while.  The universe will survive.  Even God took a day off.  And we are not God.  We aren’t cyborgs, either.  We are made in the image of God.  We are human beings.

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA.



[1] William Saletan, “The War on Sleep. There's a Military Arms Race to Build Soldiers Who Fight Without Fatigue,” Cited 22 March 2014, Online: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/superman/2013/05/sleep_deprivation_in_the_military_modafinil_and_the_arms_race_for_soldiers.html.


[2] Jonathan Crary, 24/7: Terminal Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep (London & New York: Verso, 2013), 10.

[3] Exodus 1:13-14a.

[4] Exodus 2:24-25.
[5] Exodus 5:7-9.

Sabbath Drudgery: Cleansing the Palate (Nehemiah 13:15-19; Lent 1 (series); March 9, 2014)



Sabbath Drudgery: Cleansing the Palate

Nehemiah 13:15-19
Lent 1 (series)
March 9, 2014

Rev. John M. Caldwell, PhD
First United Methodist Church
Decorah, IA

We are tired.  Some pundits have been saying that we are war-weary, but I think it’s truer to say that we are just weary, period.

It’s true that those of us who are fortunate to have jobs are working longer hours than we have since we started keeping records.  For many of us, the jobs never really end.  Since we are able to log in to our office computers from anywhere, many employers expect us to monitor email evenings and weekends.  We feel obliged to answer our cell phones wherever we are.  We are on-call.  Like the ancient Israelites we are enthralled to a Pharaoh who has ever-increasing quotas of bricks to be produced and who has ideas about ever-decreasing labor costs.  “Fewer bricks?  Absolutely out of the question!  Oh, and find your own straw!” The beast demands our ever-increasing productivity.

But it isn’t just about work.  It’s also about the demands of parenthood.  We no longer trust our children (or the world) enough to allow our children explore and learn about their world on their own.  We distrust their imagination.  We have constructed mostly imaginary dangers from which they must be protected at all times.  We have bicycles and helmets for each member of the family and they sit in the garage, mostly unused, because we are fearful of allowing our children to explore their neighborhoods and town and we certainly don’t have time to go with them.  Our children are under house arrest.

One of the few exceptions is for their organized activities.  It is written somewhere that children must participate in all sorts of organized athletics: soccer, swimming, gymnastics, to barely scratch the surface.  None of them bad in themselves, they come to dominate the life of families. Parents are reduced to taxi drivers, shuttling their children to and from practices, games and tournaments.  There is no respite.  There are no days off.  Parents are tired. 

Children are tired, and not just from their athletics, either.  They have homework.  Lots of homework.  We should have known that something had gone terribly wrong when backpacks became a necessary part of back-to-school wardrobes for elementary school children. 

And then, in addition to the demands of school and sports there are the beastly demands made on children by the media.  They watch a great deal of television.  They text each other.  The cyclopean eye of the hand-held video screen demands their attention and they give it.  Our children are sleep-deprived and so are their parents.

You might imagine that there will eventually come an end to the demands, at least when we retire, but as many people have discovered “re-tired” just means “tired again.” 

The beast has us in its shackles and the worst of it is that the beast has taught us to call this “freedom.”

Our culture has a troubled relationship with rest.  Rest dangles in front of us like a carrot on the end of a stick, just out of reach, maintaining a tantalizing distance while we move faster and faster.  The beast has a thousand reasons why we can’t rest just now and we accept them:  There is too much to do.  If I don’t get this done, bad things will happen.  There are people depending on me.  Even, God is depending on me. 

Mostly, though, we can’t stop because we can’t stand the anxiety that arises in us when we do.

This is one of the shapes of “evil, injustice and oppression” that we face and that we are called to resist.  But while the specifics may differ, our troubled relationship with rest and with time itself remains the same.  Fortunately for us our ancestors in faith were given some tools, some strategies for resisting the unending demands for production and consumption.  Among these the most important, for my money, is the gift of Sabbath.  

During Lent it is traditional even in Protestant churches to focus on spiritual disciplines like prayer, fasting and self-denial.  This Lent I am preaching a series on the Sabbath as a spiritual discipline and a way of resisting Pharaoh and his beastly demands.

The bad news is, as soon as I mention Sabbath, we throw up walls of resistance.  If we don’t deal with those right at the beginning, if we don’t deal with the distortions and perversions of the Sabbath we will never to the heart of the Jewish blessing that serves as a Sabbath greeting: Shabbat shalom, Sabbath peace!

The Sabbath was given to a band of escaped slaves as part of a way of life, a political and socio-economic system, that was offered as an alternative to life under Pharaoh and Pharaoh’s gods that was a life of unending toil, of constant production, of human beings whose lives have been distorted until they are machines. The Sabbath was the gift of humanity, a respite from the demands of production, the provision of time for friendship and neighborliness, for food and drink, for laughter and dancing and song, for poetry, and, yes, for worship as the deep appreciation and gratitude for life itself.

As a principle, of course, Sabbath is easy enough, but as a practice or a set of practices, it becomes more difficult.  It’s been made harder for us by the fact that the Sabbath in its final biblical form was imagined by urban Jewish elites in Babylon.  Their notion of Sabbath doesn’t always translate simply to non-urban settings.

We can see some of this being played out in our text from Nehemiah, who was sent to Jerusalem by the Persian emperor to reestablish some semblance of Jewish life in their homeland.  Nehemiah was sent as a governor for the province of Judea with the mandate of setting things to rights.  Nehemiah found that there was a lot that needed fixing.  The walls around Jerusalem were in disrepair.  Its gate was destroyed.  The Temple had been looted and burned.  But perhaps the worst of it all was the way the people were living.  They weren’t following the rules.  Especially they weren’t keeping the rules that made Jews distinct from other people: They were intermarrying.  They were not obeying the rules about ritual purity.  And they weren’t keeping the Sabbath. 

They were pressing grapes to make wine.  They were gathering grain, putting it in bags, and loading up donkeys.  They were bringing wine, grapes, figs to Jerusalem to sell on the Sabbath.  They were bringing fish from Tyre and all sorts of consumer goods and selling them on the Sabbath, in Jerusalem itself!

Nehemiah was outraged.  He resorted to shaming his subordinates.  He scolded them like children.  He accused them of making the Sabbath impure.  He threatened them with God’s wrath.  I think this reaction was unhelpful.  Instead of holding up the purpose of the Sabbath and the vision it contains for human life at its best, Nehemiah framed the question in terms of what was not permitted.  He turned a gift into a burden, a delight into a list of rules.

We can see the line that runs from Nehemiah to the illustration on our bulletin cover warning young men not to play soccer on Sunday (and perhaps especially not to play soccer on the Upper Iowa), lest God drown them, too.  Because, after all, this is what our God is like?!

Trust the Scots to take an idea to its illogical conclusion by a series of iron-clad arguments.  They excluded all sorts of innocent behavior until there wasn’t much left that was permitted on Sundays.  One Presbyterian minister from the eighteen hundreds remembers it this way:

All of a sudden everything that I had been doing last week had become wicked. Latin, Greek, Mathematics, were now wicked; so were marbles, ‘tig’ [tag], and races; so were walking, except to church, laughing, singing, except psalms, playing the flute, ‘fiddle’, or any instrument of music, reading newspapers (specially wicked), or anything except the Bible and ‘good’ books. There was scarcely anything that was safe to do from our rising in the morning until our going to bed at night, except reading the Bible, singing psalms, saying or joining in prayers, hearing sermons preached in church or at home.[1]

Some of you will remember as I do the last remnant of this way of thinking about the Sabbath embodied in the Blue Laws.  These laws (and I don’t know why they were blue) outlawed many ordinary activities on Sunday.  Grocery stores were closed.  Drug stores were open, but only so that the pharmacy could stay in service.  Gas stations, book stores, clothing stores, all closed. 

In my not particularly pious home growing up I remember these as absurd inconveniences.  What I didn’t notice then that I appreciate now is that the low-paid employees of these places were at least guaranteed a day off to spend with their families each week.  But no matter, the Blue Laws are long since dead and there are few legal restraints on the beast’s demand for production and consumption.

Thanks to Nehemiah, a legalistic understanding of Sabbath, and the Blue Laws, Sabbath has left a bad taste in our mouths.  We will have to cleanse our collective palate if we are to have any hope of receiving the gift of Shabbat shalĂ´m.  Only with the Sabbath, at least as an idea, do have any hope in resisting Pharaoh’s insatiable demands for more and more production.  Only the Sabbath promises us the rest that we need.  Only the Sabbath can provide for lives—ours as well as our children’s—that are more rather than less human, and for communities that are more rather than less humane. 

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA.






[1] Wallace, Robert. Robert Wallace. Life and Last Leaves. [no place given]: [no publisher given], 1903.  Cited on http://jasongoroncy.com/2013/04/23/on-the-doom-of-sabbath-breakers/.